Let it be known at the start that these trifling thoughts in no way constitute a full review of X-Men: The Last Stand, henceforth referred to as X3 for the sake of brevity and because it's just less pretentious. I did the same thing after I saw Mission: Impossible III, mainly because I know enough about J.J. Abrams and I just wanted to throw some stuff out there. So if you want a big, regular review, look elsewhere.
• The film was visually pleasing, so that's something. But the effects were perfunctory, not once jaw-dropping or engaging or arresting or anything you'd expect from a superhero film of this magnitude.
• X3 was so poorly structured as to be laughable. There was absolutely no drama, no tension, no build, no arc, no character dynamic. Not a thing. The film ended with a supposedly climactic battle at Alcatraz, but there was no sense that things had been building to this point, merely that the scenes had stumbled along with a minimum of grace and skill to get us to the final fight.
• Kitty Pryde is a great character, and Ellen Page is a talented actress who certainly looks the part. But it's a shame she never had much to do with the film series up to this point. Page is the third actress to play Kitty, after Sumela Kay in X-Men and Katie Stuart in X2. In Ratner's film, Kitty at least gets a few lines, though she doesn't do a lot besides flirt with Iceman, which is annoying for several reasons, mainly (1) Ice Guy has been hung up on the slutty but untouchable Rogue for two movies now, and (2) Kitty is supposed to be with Colossus. Which is a good segue:
• In what could be the weirdest change from the first two films, the character of Colossus is now an American dude named Pete, not a Russian guy named Peter. Why this change was made escapes me. And also, seriously, Kitty should stop flirting with Iceman.
• No spoilers here, so don't worry. But I will express my disgust that more than one major character was killed with the kind of cavalier manner that suggests both Ratner's inability to tell a story with the remotest semblance of competence and his lack of understanding of how to effectively utilize characters. George Lucas once callously said that anyone could manipulate the audience just by showing a kitten onscreen and then having someone break its neck. But Ratner doesn't understand that having a canonical, integral character mutter five lines before getting utterly disintegrated by a villain is just a boneheaded thing to do. Trust me, it's possible to kill a briefly used character and make it an emotionally resonant moment for the audience. Not to mention that having one of the X-Men — not just a random mutant, or even a student at Xavier’s academy, but a full-on member of the team — choose to give up their powers by taking the scientifically developed "cure" for mutancy is stupid and weak and pathetic and pick your own adjective.
• Ratner seems to be pandering to the fanboys by introducing more and more classic characters. After all, who doesn't want to see Beast onscreen? And I will concede that the casting of Kelsey Grammer for that role is beyond inspired; therefore, I'm obviously curious how much a role Ratner played in that decision. But more characters means less overall development, which is one of the main reasons there's no tension or story. It's all but impossible to do anything with a main cast of 13 mutants, surrounded by a host of others, in 1 hour and 45 minutes. And to the naysayers who would complain that I'm an idiot for asking for some kind of character development in a superhero movie, (1) shut up, and (2) it's possible. Very possible.
• The real hell of it, the real kick in the nuts, is how great X3 could have been. The story line about a cure for mutancy has its roots in the surprisingly good cartoon from my childhood and Joss Whedon's run of recent "Astonishing X-Men" stories. There's a great possibility here to talk about rights, and prejudice, and government's control over citizens it might deem different. There could have been a real nuance to the story, too: It's not just mutants vs. humans, or good guys vs. bad. All the mutants want freedom, to be able to live without fear of discriminationor extermination, and it's how far each one is willing to go to achieve that freedom that determines whether they're "good" or "bad." There's not really a clear line between the two; they exist at either end of a continuum, a sliding scale ruled by your willingness to compromise yourself for the pursuit of your goals. But, well, Ratner doesn't have the faintest glint of any of this. He has no idea just how close he came to telling a truly epic story. And that's the biggest disappointment.
|
|
||||||
|
The Photo
the info
Los Angeles, California I'm a twentysomething white male with ambitions to be a professional film critic and generally spend my days getting paid to watch movies and write about it. I try not to think too hard about how I want to build my life around talking about other people's creations and not mine. A compulsive reader and stubborn cineaste, I take an often contrary stance to my more fundamentalist peers and upbringing by celebrating the pursuit of the good, and the Good, in life, love, art and film. If you watched enough episodes of a few TV shows ("The Hungry and the Hunted," "The Cut Man Cometh," "The Body," "Waiting in the Wings," "Out of Gas," "April is the Cruelest Month," "20 Hours in America," "Colonial Day" for starters), you would understand me completely, and you'd also realize that much of my worldview and philosophical insights are heavily influenced by fictional works/programs, and many of the good things I've said in my life are just a regurgitation of someone else's imaginings. I guess I was made to be a film critic. This Month
Login
the counter
the ratings
Search
the library
The Words
the shots
www.flickr.com
This is a Flickr badge showing public photos from dan_carlson. Make your own badge here.
the politics
The Alumni
The Clock
|
Brett Ratner Is A Bad Director. And A Bad Person On The Grand Scale Of Human Existence. But Mainly A Bad Director.
Comments
Re: Brett Ratner Is A Bad Director. And A Bad Person On The Grand Scale Of Human Existence. But Mainly A Bad Director.
by
Trixie
on Tue 30 May 2006 05:25 AM PDT | Profile | Permanent Link
Just one quick thing -
I went back and watched X2 with some friends on Sunday specifically to see about Colossus thing cause I was wondering the same thing about his being Russian. In X2, for his very brief part, he does not have a Russian accent and they do not call him by name (that I noticed). So they were consistent between the two movies, but inconsistent with the comics. Re: Brett Ratner Is A Bad Director. And A Bad Person On The Grand Scale Of Human Existence. But Mainly A Bad Director.
by
Mara
on Wed 31 May 2006 11:31 AM PDT | Permanent Link
I didn't even realize said character was dead until they out and out said it. Maybe I'm just an idiot, or maybe - gasp - Brett Ratner is a bad director.
My favorite moment has to be when Magneto sets the bridge down on the ground and suddenly, it goes from day to night! I actually laughed out loud in the theatre at this. Re: Brett Ratner Is A Bad Director. And A Bad Person On The Grand Scale Of Human Existence. But Mainly A Bad Director.
I agree with you on every point. I was pretty disappointed with the movie as a whole, and there are several more points I'd like to add to yours:
- Rogue is useless. All she can do is suck the power from people she touches and complain. If being moody is a superhuman power, she should be the next Professor X. - How is it that every rag-tag mutant Magneto meets is instantly part of his inner circle? Seriously, the guy who multiplies himself? The girl who claps her hands really loud? These are the people Magneto decides to surround himself with. - Half-way through the battle scene at Alcatraz, I thought, "Is this the climax?" It felt like it came out of nowhere. Just like you said: no tension, no build, no arc. - If Magneto has ultimate control over the metal skeleton of Wolverine, why doesn't he just throw him into the middle of the bay instead of letting him slash his way through half of Magneto's mutant army. - Most mutants would be better off fighting with a machine gun rather than using their powers alone. Re: Brett Ratner Is A Bad Director. And A Bad Person On The Grand Scale Of Human Existence. But Mainly A Bad Director.
by
Dan Carlson
on Thu 01 Jun 2006 12:39 PM PDT | Profile | Permanent Link
Trixie: You're right. I went back this morning and checked X2, and Colossus has an American accent. He's still credited with his Russian name, though, and it's beyond me why they Americanized his character. As for his accent, I stand most humbly corrected.
Mara: I'm glad someone else caught that. I usually don't talk during movies at all, but when the scene changed from day tonight in 5 seconds, I was forced to turn to a friend and whisper, "Where'd the daylight go?" Stupid Ratner. Cody: Yeah, Rogue is much cooler after she absorbs Ms. Marvel's ability to fly. (I'll admit I double-checked that against Wikipedia, but I was still enough of a loser to know the basic facts on my own.) The cartoon was better. I was hoping she'd reappear at the final battle, use her powers to weaken or destroy Pyro, and in so doing rejoin the team and re-form her bond with Iceman. But no dice. Weak movie all around. Re: Brett Ratner Is A Bad Director. And A Bad Person On The Grand Scale Of Human Existence. But Mainly A Bad Director.
by
Alan Baxter
on Thu 01 Jun 2006 08:08 PM PDT | Permanent Link
I have to agree on the whole about this movie. I was fairly surprised at the directions it took. The overall effect of this movie on me was that it left me thinking about all the people we kept seeing queueing up for the cure. (I talk about it on my blog if you're interested.) Fancy focussing on Rogue when the possibilities there are legion!
|
the post
the quotes
"The critic is the only independent source of information. The rest is advertising." "Film lovers are sick people." "I hope I strike a blow for chubby bald men everywhere. I hope they rise like an army." "Let others praise ancient times, I am glad I was born in these." the humor
the screens
Pajiba
HSX IMDb MovieWeb Box Office Mojo Dark Horizons BFI RT New York Magazine Cinema Treasures Metaphilm Onion A.V. Club Film Comment Criterion Empire Drew's Script-O-Rama MCN Greatest Films Second Spin AFI The Hollywood Reporter Metacritic Defamer Dave Poland Dave Kehr AllMovie Movie City Indie Austin Movie Blog The Screengrab GreenCine Daily FirstShowing Fimoculous Chicago Reader: On Film Sunset Gun Bordwell and Thompson the tube
The Plugs
The Sis
The Oldest Guy I Know Creatum This Guy Borrowed My Dave Shirt Historian Emeritus Never Met This Guy Tucker Tucker Mother [Uh-Oh] Steve Holt Peter-Wecker Man vs. Clown! Susan the Canadian Halbey RozieD J. Scott Kendall-Ball Geoff Klock Bells On A Special Way of Being Afraid Down in Texas One More Curious Mile Jennifer, Who's From Weatherford, And Now Lives In Virginia They Call The Wind Jehiah Bad Movie Club Girish That Little Round-Headed Boy Tom The Dog's You Know What I Like? Hoyden's Kibitzing Brady Lane My Best Friend's Girl Mimi in NY No More Marriages! My Experiments Miles To Go ... litelysalted Recent Entries
Month Archive
the wisdom
Remembering speechlessly we seek the great forgotten language, the lost lane-end into heaven, a stone, a leaf, an unfound door. Where? When?
O lost, and by the wind grieved, ghost, come back again. — Look Homeward, Angel, Thomas Wolfe Conservatives are not necessarily stupid, but most stupid people are conservatives. — John Stuart Mill We are all under the same mental calamity; we have all forgotten our names. We have all forgotten what we really are. All that we call common sense and rationality and practicality and positivism only means that for certain dead levels of our life we forget that we have forgotten. All that we call spirit and art and ecstasy only means that for one awful instant we remember that we forget. — G.K. Chesterton We were, for the briefest of moments, something greater than the sum of our uncertain parts; we were youth itself, in all its painful glory and sharp joy. — August Van Zorn There is a time in the lives of most writers when they are vulnerable, when the vivid dreams and ambitions of childhood seem to pale in the harsh sunlight of what we call the real world. In short, there's a time when things can go either way. — Stephen King Los Angeles, give me some of you! Los Angeles come to me the way I came to you, my feet over your streets, you pretty town I loved you so much, you sad flower in the sand, you pretty town. — Ask the Dust, John Fante |
||||








